Back to Table Of Contents
PART C -- CRIMINAL LUNATICS -- DETENTION.
Medical history sheet to be sent to Government.-- The accompanying form (Printed at the end of Chapter 17-C as an Appendix) has been prescribed by the Provincial Government for all cases in which the papers of a criminal lunatic are sent to it for orders. Unless this form is completed, it is impossible to arrive at any safe decision regarding the period for which it will be necessary to detain him.
2. Same should be sent to Mental Hospital.-- The same form should invariably be used when a criminal lunatic is sent direct to a Mental Hospital by a Magistrate or Court. ***[...]
3. Memo of principles to be observed in dealing with the cases of criminal lunatics.-- Attention is called to the following memorandum, embodying the views of certain experts as to the principles which should apply generally in dealing with the cases of criminal lunatics. This memorandum is only intended to indicate broadly the action which may ordinarily be taken. The case of every criminal lunatic should be considered separately and dealt with on its own merits, and if *[in] any case the opinion of the officers responsible for advice regarding it is that the principles embodied in the memorandum do not apply, the action recommended should be that which the special circumstances of the case suggest to the experience of the officers concerned as the most appropriate.
-------------
(1) Crime.-- Offences against the person. Intoxicating drugs. Type-Acute or chronic mania.-- If the crime be against the person, the cause, the use of intoxicating drugs, and the type of insanity, acute or chronic mania, a period of three years should be spent in an asylum free from all signs of insanity before any action is taken.
(2) Crime.-- Offences against the person. Cause.-- Other than intoxicating drugs. Type.-- Acute or chronic mania.-- If the crime be an offence against the person, the type of insanity, acute or chronic mania, and the alleged cause not the use of intoxicating drugs, a period of at least four years of complete freedom from insanity should be spent in an asylum before action is taken.
(3) Crime.-- Not an offence against the person, but where mental attitude is aggressive. Type.-- acute or chronic mania.-- If the crime be not an offence against the person, but the lunatic has at any time exhibited dangerous or violent tendencies, a period of at least four years should be spent in an asylum before any recommendation is made for his transfer to jail or for his release.
(4) Crime.-- Not an offence against the person, or, if so, trivial in its nature mental attitude not aggressive.-- If the crime be not an offence against the person and there is no history that the lunatic was at any time aggressive, he may generally be treated ***[...] as if he were a non-criminal lunatic. The Provincial Government will generally be guided in such cases by the recommendations of the Visitors and of the Superintendent of the Asylum in which the lunatic is confined.
(5) Crime.-- Murder. Type.-- Melancholia.-- If the crime be murder and the type of insanity be melancholia, a period of at least six years complete freedom from insanity should be passed in an asylum before action is taken.
(5) (a) If the crime be one against the person, and the lunatic has been originally confined in the asylum under the provisions of section 466 **[of the] Code of Criminal Procedure and has subsequently sufficiently recovered to stand his trial and has been acquitted under section 470 of the Code, it will be necessary that the lunatic shall be sent back to the asylum to undergo the same period of complete freedom from insanity in accordance with the above rules before a recommendation by the visitors can be made for the lunatic`s release.
(6) Crime.-- Attempted suicide. Type.-- Melancholia.-- If the crime be attempt to commit suicide, the type melancholia and if the lunatic has not exhibited any violent tendencies while under observation, some relaxations of the rules may be permitted according to circumstances, age, period of detention, *[etc.]
(7) Crime.-- Offences against a person. Type.-- Chronic mania of irritable aggressive kind.-- If the crime be an offence against a person, the type chronic mania of the irritable aggressive kind, it will seldom be possible to release the lunatic during continuance of insanity except in advanced age and on exceptional security.
(8) Crime.-- Offences not against a person, or of trivial nature. Type.-- Mental attitude not aggressive.-- If the crime be not an offence against the person, or, if an offence against the person, of trivial nature and the lunatic has never exhibited aggressive symptoms, he may generally be treated ***[...] as if he were a non-criminal lunatic and the Provincial Government dealing with his case under section 474 of the Criminal Procedure Code, will be guided mainly by the recorded opinion of the Superintendent of the Asylum as to the propriety of releasing him, and by the recommendations of the Visitors.
4. ***[Omitted].
N. B.-- The ultimate responsibility for the preparation of this form rests with the committing officer who must see that the requisite information is supplied by the Police and the Medical Officer without undue delay.
1. Name of patient in full, and caste, or race.
2. Name of patient's father.
3. Sex and age of patient.
4. Marks whereby the patient may be identified.
5. Married or single or widowed.
6. Condition of life and previous occupation (if any)
7. Religion.
8. Place of birth and recent place of abode. *
9. Whether homeless or living with relatives. **
10. Pervious history and habits. #
11. Whether any member of patient's family has been or is affected with insanity.
12. Whether the attack is the first attack of insanity or not.
13. Age (if known) at outset of first attack.
14. Duration and nature of any previous attacks.
15. Supposed cause of insanity. ##
16. Supposed exciting cause of present attack. *#
QUESTIONS TO BE ANSWERED BY POLICE AND MEDICAL OFFICER.
1. Duration of existing attack.
2. Whether suicidal.
3. Whether dangerous to others.
QUESTIONS TO BE ANSWERED BY MEDICAL OFFICER ALONE.
1. State of bodily health. ***
2. Symptoms exhibited.
3. Whether subject to epilepsy or any other disease.
LHC - Shahrah-e-Quaid-e-Azam - Lahore - Pakistan
Computer Cell, Lahore High Court.
Comments Or Suggestions to webmaster@lhc.gov.pk
For Further Information: info@lhc.gov.pk